I'm in California and pay about the same as well, but I financed my bike and my deductible is $200 bucks. I'm 26 now, still in college, and this is considered a big purchase for me. My insurance was through Geico since I already have two cars with them.
2017 Honda Rebel 300A
1997 Honda Prelude SH
"Little by little, what you’ve begun will naturally become important to you. What you need at the start is a little bit of curiosity."